Finding Ninee » Sharing our parenting and special needs stories with heart and humor.

Our Land: Am I a Glass Child?

OurLandBannerFindingNinee

Today’s Our Land post has been written by a lovely and amazing person, who has generously contributed to The Land of Empathy and Wonder in the past. With the following post, she’s choosing to remain anonymous. Her anonymity obviously takes nothing away from her powerful and amazing words. I hope that you’ll let her know how important her words are, here. Because honestly? I read this three times in a row and still feel goosebumps. And power. And well. Here, see for yourself.

Our Land: Am I a Glass Child?

As the parent of a special needs child, who had many medical complexities that automatically qualified him for the best of care and services from the minute he was home from the hospital, I’ve always felt supported in my special needs child’s care.

Where I’ve felt less supported is in the care of my typical needs son.  Whenever I have expressed concerns about the impact on him, nearly every single person has shrugged off my concerns, and said “he’ll be fine, kids are resilient.”  These responses have brought out a rage in me that I had a hard time understanding.  I didn’t say much in response, but the sarcastic smartass who lives in my head quickly retorted, “Yes, I’m sure letting him fester with those bad feelings is great for his long-term resiliency.”

The funny thing is, I’m not a person who holds much in.  If I feel strongly about something, I will typically defend my case.  On this topic, however, I kept quiet. Still, each “he’s fine” kicked me in the gut.  Finally, my concerns were validated; my son’s teacher referred him for an evaluation by the mental health team at his school.  She too was noticing some differences in him…very classic differences in siblings who deal with chronically ill brothers and sisters.  After the evaluation, he was enrolled in a play therapy program and, over time, we are starting to see improvements in his coping abilities.

As he improved, I thought my anger would diminish.  Someone heard me and we are getting the help our son needs.  It’s still a work in progress, but I’m really proud of how, with help, my son has proven to be resilient.  However, my anger about people disregarding it still lingers.

I couldn’t put my finger on exactly why I was so angry about society’s nonchalance to the needs of a sibling of a child with special needs until I came across Alicia Arenas’ Ted Talk, “Recognizing Glass Children.”  Alicia is a sibling to two special needs brothers and she talks about her story in hopes of making more people aware of the impact of the sibling.

I was drawn to the video with my son in mind, and as Alicia talked, I did recognize him in her words.  I also realized that I recognized myself.  As she spoke, I thought back to the quiet little girl that I was…the one who was always “the good girl.”  The very next memory was of me being 22 and just out of college, living alone for the first time – alone with my thoughts – and I remember writing this.

My turn

On the next page I continued, “When do I get to be the one who screws up?  When do get to make the wrong decision and just think about myself and what I want in each moment?  When do I get to be the selfish one?”  With the memory of these words came the realization that I, too, was a glass child.  By Alicia’s definition, glass children are not given their name because they are weak.  On the contrary, they tend to be very strong.  They are given the name glass children, because they are often looked through, rather than being truly seen.

I’m the youngest in my family.  I have two older brothers.  My eldest brother had severe dyslexia and even more severe anger problems.  He was always in fights, always rebelling against my parents and terrible in school.  I now believe his anger stemmed a lot from the fact that he too, is a glass child.  When he was two our second brother was born extremely prematurely and had several years of medical needs.  Even when this preemie brother outgrew his medical conditions, he still had the typical preemie behavior problems.  I’ve been told, researchers are starting to lump preemies into their own behavior group – in some ways it resembles ADHD and in other ways bi-polar.  My earliest memories are of this middle brother being in and out of the principal’s office.  As we got older he was often in and out of the backseat of cop cars.  My parents also had some issues.  My dad was a serial cheater and even though I was too young to know exactly what was going on, no child is too young to realize when their parent’s relationship is strained.  My mom was molested as a child and has struggled with mental health issues her entire adult life.  Complicating matters, my parents were often stressed on how to raise my brothers.  They didn’t feel the school district was helping and so they spent a lot of time trying to get them the help they needed.

I don’t want to make it seem like I had no time or attention from my parents as a child.  I did, and I knew I was loved, but so often, it was just expected that I would be the good one.  One brother was in learning disability classes, the other in behavior disability classes and I was in gifted and talented.  It was assumed I could take care of myself and keep focused on being “good” and “smart.”  I spent a lot of time alone in my room reading and writing…being good.

As if being a tall, rail thin twelve year old girl with a grown woman set of boobs wasn’t awkward enough, it was also when I was that age that the thin thread holding our family together started to unravel.  My parents finally separated, my oldest brother ran away and stayed with a friend’s family for a while and then had a brief stint in the military (his rebellious nature made him a bad recruit), my middle brother started getting into the real trouble that had cops coming around and my dad had the great idea that if one anti-depressant made him feel better, the entire bottle might really do the trick.  The following year my mom had a nervous breakdown and, so, in a little more than a year, I had both parents spend month-long stays in the psych-ward.

As Alicia Aranas’ described a glass child, she described me; I was good, I was responsible, I did what I was supposed to do and, even as the youngest child, did my best to take care of everyone else… all while feeling incredibly invisible.  To me, it felt like our family was drama 1, drama 2, drama 3, drama 4 and then me, the afterthought.

Unlike, Alicia Aranas (whose brothers’ needs were much more significant than mine) I never had thoughts of suicide.  I didn’t have mental health issues growing up or really even as an adult.  To most, I probably seem like a pretty typical person.  I’d probably be considered a “good case” outcome of a glass child.  I’m still quite responsible, sometimes really stubborn and over time, I found ways to make sure I felt heard (typically by being smartass).  I can also say, being a glass child is lonely even as an adult surrounded by friends and a family of her own.  I have zero idea of how to ask for help.  I never want to impose and my expectation is that only I will take care of me.  Clearly that’s a struggle in my marriage – my husband wants to think I need him in some ways too.  Of course, I do, but I’m not sure how to show it.  Fortunately he loves me in spite of this issue.

As soon as I could, I moved out of my hometown.  I wanted away from my family and their drama.  I still live away from my family and I love them, but I keep a degree of distance.  I like feeling opaque.  Even today, when I’m with them, I feel more transparent.

I never want my son to feel transparent.  I feel like we’re making some great steps with him being in play therapy.  My husband and I work to make sure he gets one-on-one time with both of us.  We make an effort, but I know he still feels his needs get placed behind his brother’s.  Our efforts in our family will continue and I don’t want to stop there.  It’s important to keep having this conversation because kids like him and me and so many others; we deserve to be seen.

We deserve for our hurt and emotional needs to be acknowledged and we should not just be expected to outgrow that hurt.  Yes, kids are resilient, they are also human and our brightest hope for the future, so let’s help them feel opaque.

Please, don’t forget the emotional needs of the siblings.


  • Kerri - This post completely hit home for me. I am always wondering how to make sure Allie doesn’t become that glass child. That she gets the focus and attention she deserves. While having a special sib makes her more empathetic and aware it also drains on her I am sure. She always seems to take it in stride that it is easy to forget she may be struggling.

    I am also the “good girl” except I was the oldest who tried to keep under the radar in a drama filled family. Love at a distance sums up my relationship with my immediate family. It is always safer that way. On the upside it protects my children from being afflicted by their behaviors.

    Thank you for writing this!October 23, 2013 – 9:09 amReplyCancel

  • Kristi Campbell - Kerri,
    My bet is that you’re doing an amazing job with Allie. The fact that you think about how living with Boo affects her in both good and bad ways says a lot. Love from a distance. What a powerful description.October 23, 2013 – 9:14 amReplyCancel

  • Janine Huldie - Neither of my children have any real disabilities, but still as a mother to two, I am always fearing that one child will feel like I am giving more attention to the other then themselves. I try my best, but I think we all can have a tendency to give more attention to one over the other without even realizing it. Wonderful post and truly is so true about making sure that siblings don’t be made to feel opaque.October 23, 2013 – 9:22 amReplyCancel

  • Anita@ Losing Austin - <3

    As the sister of a missing adult, I sometimes feel that in my family- we are all so focused on him and finding him that I'm often in that place. I think I always was to some extent, but never understood it till the last few years.

    You're doing so right by your oldest, making him seen and heard, and standing up for him as well.October 23, 2013 – 10:19 amReplyCancel

  • Dana - It is so important to give a voice to glass children – thank you for sharing your story. It sounds like you are taking your own childhood experiences and making sure your son feels and knows he is opaque.October 23, 2013 – 10:45 amReplyCancel

  • Considerer - That’s a really great term, and well done for striving to give BOTH your children the support they need. I hope that you learn to ask for help – apparently that’s important. And that you find ways to make your husband feel needed. That’s also important.

    Awesome post.October 23, 2013 – 12:48 pmReplyCancel

  • Laura - Please tell your friend, thank you so very much for sharing her story. It really resonated with a lot of things that are currently going on with my family. Let her know that she’s not alone and that people appreciate her courage to share.October 23, 2013 – 1:55 pmReplyCancel

  • Tamara - Wow, that’s an amazing thought – the siblings. And the term “glass child.” I think I was a bit of a glass child after my father passed and it seemingly hit my older sister more than me. Really, she just understood more. And she was given more because maybe everyone though since I was so young, I’d be fine.
    It wasn’t the case, though. All of that pressure did sort of implode before it had to explode.
    I think about that a lot with my two kids. How no matter how different their needs are, they are still there. Their needs.October 23, 2013 – 2:38 pmReplyCancel

  • thedoseofreality - An amazing post in every way. I will be thinking about this one all night, I can tell.-AshleyOctober 23, 2013 – 8:32 pmReplyCancel

  • Kerith Stull - Even from the title of this one, I knew where you were coming from. I’ve watched that video (maybe a year ago or so). VERY compelling and SO made me think about my “other” daughter who is 23 months older than my daughter with moderate cerebral palsy (17 and 19yo respectively). This is such a side-stepped and forgotten issue. Thanks for bringing it to the forefront here.October 23, 2013 – 9:33 pmReplyCancel

  • Emily - Very well said. As my youngest son battles an illness now, I worry a lot about my two older sons. There is a program called, “super sibs” for them, but so far they have said they are not interested. But, I already see the effect this is having on them. My husband and I are expecting them to be so empathetic and understanding and mostly they are, but sometimes they don’t want to walk on egg shells and they just want to act like normal brothers. It’s all a very hard balance. Thank you for sharing your story with us.October 23, 2013 – 9:51 pmReplyCancel

  • Katia - On a theoretical level this was a fascinating read, as I’ve never come across this term before and you did such a great job explaining it. On an emotional level I ached for your glass child and for yourself. I’m an only child but I feel that I’ve taken on this role in some friendships and work relationships I had and therefore easily connected with the words you wrote in your notebook and the ones you wrote in your post. Very well written.October 23, 2013 – 10:26 pmReplyCancel

  • Kristi Campbell - Janine,
    I think all parents feel like this (and all siblings, too as I wonder if my brothers wonder whether I favorite one more) but I don’t think you have anything to worry about…

    Anita,
    I can imagine that with so much of your life focused on finding Austin, that that is very true…and very similar, actually…

    Dana.
    Here is to opaque.

    Considerer,
    Yes, yes. yes, making all feel important, including the self. Her self.October 23, 2013 – 11:19 pmReplyCancel

  • Kristi Campbell - Laura,
    She knows, I’m pretty sure she’s reading these. And thank you. Hugs.

    Tamara,
    YES. They are still there. Their needs. You.

    Dose
    xo
    —-
    Kerith,
    I need to watch the video again. Love the author of this !!!October 23, 2013 – 11:21 pmReplyCancel

  • Kristi Campbell - Emily,
    It is a hard balance. I noticed the same with my step-daughter, and feel like I failed her, huge…sigh…

    Katia,
    yes. what you said. me, too…October 23, 2013 – 11:23 pmReplyCancel

  • Out One Ear - Linda Atwell - Wow. I understand your pain, your concern. My son was three years younger than my daughter. She created a lot of drama and I often (as my son grew older) saw him slip out the door and run to the neighbor’s house. He just didn’t like all the noise and fuss Lindsey made. When we traveled, Lindsey turned what often started out as pleasant family vacations into total busts. I wanted these idyllic family getaways, but they never happened when Lindsey was with us. Michael just seemed to disappear into a book to avoid her drama. Lindsey finally asked not to go because travel caused her a great deal of anxiety. The thought of not taking her with us caused me a great deal of anxiety. Until we tried it. My daughter stayed with grandparents (which she loved!) and we had one-on-one alone time with our son who loved to travel. We sent Lindsey postcards. (she still loves to get mail). Everyone ended up being happy. I worried what others would think about our decision, but in the end, it really helped us develop a special bond with our son. Lindsey still gets the majority of the attention in our family. At 33, she lives down the road. Michael moved to Texas. He calls, but personally, I think he likes being farther away from his sister. It’s more peaceful there. I hope you find a balance. Some people may not agree with our way to find it. But it worked for us. Each family will have to figure out what works for them.October 24, 2013 – 12:19 amReplyCancel

  • Chris Carter - Oh how powerful this post is! It hits all the nerves that a child growing up in a family dynamic with a special needs child has…

    My heart cries out for this precious soul! In so many ways…

    It cries out for those who are silently trying to be good, and survive a world with a sibling who has any special needs.

    Thank you- for sharing such a fragile part of your life- and for exposing the truth in what needs to be addressed in ALL families with special needs kids. Those precious siblings… oh how I have such a heart for them!October 24, 2013 – 1:43 amReplyCancel

  • Yvonne - This is such an interesting and illuminating post. As I read it I was reminded of how I used to feel when our girls were young and the younger one needed so much attention after being born extremely premature and having a few close calls. I have never heard of the term “glass child” before, but this post explains it very well. Our older daughter (aged 17 months when her sister was born) was often left with little warning at her grandparents or with friends as well as suddenly starting at a nursery. For years this seemed to have more impact on her than it did on her sister – she was clingy and often anxious. We have been very fortunate, and now our girls are in their teens and both are absolutely fine.

    I do think that talking about it with your children helps, though we are also lucky that our younger daughter mostly outgrew her health issues.October 24, 2013 – 4:35 pmReplyCancel

  • Rachel - My father died when I was young, and I always felt I had to keep it together for my mom. I relate to this post, although none of my siblings have special needs. I love that you recognized that something in yourself that was getting triggered by the comments about your son’s supposed resiliency, as well as the fact that you got him help with his struggles. He clearly is not transparent to you. Brava for ending the cycle! Powerful post!October 24, 2013 – 10:13 pmReplyCancel

  • Kimberly - This is a huge window into the dynamics of these families. I’m reading the comments and everyone agrees. All of us were healthy, but I was the oldest of 5 and was kind of thrown to the side…as the good one…I can’t even compare that to this. I’m having a hard time putting it into words. But thank you for this.October 26, 2013 – 8:48 amReplyCancel

  • Sarah Almond - I do wonder if my daughter feels this way sometimes. My older son has ADD, OCD and behavior problems as well as most likely being on the spectrum. While we try to approach it positively so we don’t reinforce his negative behaviors, we feel the need to address the bad behavior ie hitting other children, refusing to comply with the teacher, etc. She has just started kindergarten and so far school has been perfect, unlike the nightmare that started when her brother entered school.

    She is all for encouraging her brother and cheering him on when he does well, and we try to give her lots of extra attention and talk with her frequently. So far she seems like a well adjusted, happy kindergartener, and I hope it continues!

    Thank you for writing this!October 27, 2013 – 12:29 pmReplyCancel

  • The Anonymous Author - Thank you to everyone for the thoughtful responses and support of this piece. It’s wonderful to see others sharing in the conversation – the more we think about siblings, the better they can support their siblings into adulthood and, just as importantly, have their own sense of identity that goes beyond being “the good one”. xoxo to Kristi for sharing my anonymous dirty laundry.October 27, 2013 – 4:50 pmReplyCancel

  • K - I read this post last week but didn’t realize that I forgot to comment. I know I’m a little late, but I just want to say thank you — thank you for remembering the glass child, for bringing this to Our Land…because it really is SO important. Thank you for giving these children a voice. This post is beautiful on so many levels.November 7, 2013 – 10:36 amReplyCancel

  • Andrea Binner - Thank youJuly 22, 2023 – 2:40 pmReplyCancel

  • Andrea Binner - I am no longer a drinker of alcohol. But I have often compared myself to Mr. Cellophane from the musical Chicago. When I have stood at a bar, waiting for the bArtender to notice me, they will serve everyone around me & then say “I didn’t notice you.” Anyone else have this experience?July 22, 2023 – 2:44 pmReplyCancel

Your email is never published or shared. Required fields are marked *

*

*

N e v e r   m i s s   a   n e w   p o s t !